- What we do
- Our impact
- The Policy Centre
Pledge your support
Help us represent the SME voice and join us in shaping the sector.
- Research & insights
- Training & funding
- Tools & resources
- Alliance
- Skills Awards

Enginuity briefing on the Milburn Review
Date
19/11/2026
Category
The Policy Centre , News
Alan Milburn's Government-commissioned independent review "From a Welfare State to a Working State" has been long awaited by employers, education providers, and Government. It aims to tackle the growing challenge of youth inactivity by suggesting reforms to welfare, skills, and education policy.
(Read the review in full: From a Welfare State to a Working State: a new settlement for the next generation - GOV.UK)
Milburn has set ambitious aims to reduce the number of young people not in education, employment or training (NEET) to around 5% by 2036, provide an additional 500,000 education and employment opportunities, and offer 25,000 pre-apprenticeship places and 270,000 under-25 apprenticeship starts per year by 2036.
The report calls for an expansion of vital vocational pathways, while acknowledging the significant challenges holding industry back from creating jobs that young people need, and calling for additional support for employers.
The costs for the recommended changes will be significant, with Milburn asking for an initial £500 million of investment; the report states that total investment would fall somewhere around £5.8 billion. Here’s what the review says of relevance for the engineering and manufacturing sector.
New financial incentives for employers
Milburn’s report calls for Government to make it financially worthwhile for employers to hire young people:
- Employers who take on a young person who has been NEET for six months to receive a £3,000 payment and an extra £2,000 for taking on a young person facing “substantially greater barriers”. An additional Small Business Premium of £2,000 for businesses with 50 employees or less
- Increase in the payment provided to employers providing apprenticeships for young people from £2,000 to £2,500, extended to levy payers.
National Insurance Contributions (NICs)
- Milburn calls not for a reversal of the 2025 changes to NICs, but for a five-year glide path towards lower NIC for workers aged 21 to 24, starting in the hospitality sector. This would include doubling the point at which NI becomes payable for young people from £5,000 to £10,000.
Apprenticeships
Milburn's core apprenticeship recommendation is for Government to fund 100% of youth apprentices, regardless of the size of the company.
- This would be paid for by reducing the funding for post-25 apprentices by 25%. Milburn warns that the Government should be willing to increase this reduction to 50% if necessary
- Milburn also proposes the removal of the existing "topslice" taken by the Treasury from employer apprenticeship levy payments.
Pre-apprenticeships
- An additional 25,000 pre-apprenticeship opportunities using existing Level 1 provision and Level 2 Occupational Certificates.
The new Youth Opportunity Service (YOS) and Youth Opportunity Guarantee (YOG)
The proposed YOS is designed to be the “one front door” for young people and employers.
- The YOS will be responsible for facilitating the YOG, the Youth Support Guarantee, and work experience for young people. It will build on existing organisations and reflect existing local support structures
- The YOS will become the local front door through which employers can recruit young people, and get support to sustain them in work.
The proposed YOG builds on the Government's existing Youth Guarantee but offers an enhanced safety net for young people.
- Government subsidies for employers (as seen above)
- A promise of a Further Education (FE) place, pre-apprenticeship, Level 2 and Level 3 technical learning, and Higher Education (HE) or university study where appropriate
- Commitment to provide work placements of up to 12 weeks, continue sector-based Work Academy Programmes (SWAP), and supported internships
- Structured 13-week volunteering programmes available through a civic service
- Tailored support for young people looking to start a new business
- The backstop – Government to commit to securing, and paying for, a six-month job with an employer if a young person has been NEET for 12 months.
Devolution
Milburn is calling for Strategic Authorities (SAs) to take on significantly more responsibility for young people in their local area, stating that they should be responsible for all participation across ages 16 to 24.
SAs are being called on to:
- Develop an Area Youth Participation Plan
- Provide "pathway maps" demonstrating how choices made at 14, 16, and 18 connect to further study, apprenticeships, or employment
- Push greater diversity of provision by identifying gaps in local skills pipelines and sponsoring funding proposals to central Government where needed.
Milburn is calling for Government to provide multi-year funding agreements (Participation Agreements) to cover employment support, the guarantees, skills, training, and re-engagement.
The report calls for government to allocate an initial 10% of the apprenticeship budget each year to mayoral and other strategic authorities.
Government should set the overall purpose and funding rules, but places should use labour market knowledge and employer relationships to:
- Strengthen employer engagement
- Generate opportunities
- Fund training costs
- Respond to local skills shortages, connecting young people to sectors with growing demand.
Schools and Further Education
Milburn’s report envisages a more modular approach to learning which allows students to combine different interests and experiences, with schools placing greater focus on work readiness.
- Every publicly funded technical or vocational course, including V Levels, to contain some work experience elements which would be co-ordinated and supported by the YOS
- FE funding to be tied more closely to a new programme of pre-apprenticeships, apprenticeships, and technical routes
- Milburn asks Government to update funding arrangements where participation exceeds forecasts to support an additional 150,000 18- to 24-year-olds over the next decade
- Milburn is calling for the establishment of an Open University for Skills: a national digital college through which people can find and accumulate accredited modules from FE, HE, and approved providers.
How Milburn suggests Government is held to account:
- Publish a Youth Employment Cost Index every two years which itemises the financial impact of its decisions on the youth labour market
- Continue to direct the Low Pay Commission to judge the pace of convergence against the critical goal of protecting youth employment
- Introduce the Youth Opportunity Test to assess the potential impact of policy on youth participation.
What does it mean for SMEs?
The review recognises that employers need more support, and sets out some provisions to provide it. However, the report also places significant responsibility on employers.
- The Milburn review gives important weight and recognition to the fact that employers need more support to create entry-level opportunities. Enhanced incentives, support for further education, and an ongoing commitment to prioritise work readiness are positive steps towards reducing youth inactivity, and providing engineering and manufacturing businesses with a skilled workforce
- The Youth Opportunity Guarantee places significant responsibility on employers to provide work experience, work placements, and apprenticeships. SMEs need targeted and extensive support, but some of the measures businesses need most are either missing or risk arriving too slowly. Engineering and manufacturing may not see NIC relief for years, while the review does not go far enough in addressing the cost and capacity involved in supporting a young person. While 100% funding for under-25 apprenticeships is welcome, this will have limited impact if funding bands make specialist engineering standards financially unviable to deliver
- A youth guarantee is only meaningful if there is an employer at the other end able to provide the opportunity. The critical lever in the success of these recommendations will be making recruitment and training viable for the businesses needed to deliver it.
What next?
The Government has accepted the direction of the Milburn Review, and has recognised the need for a “fundamental reshaping” of the system. A White Paper setting out full plans in detail will be published in the next few months, with legislation to follow.
Government has made immediate commitments to the following initiatives:
- Locally-led youth services bringing together health, skills, and youth support in one place, starting from next year
- Mayors and local leaders to shape youth services around local needs
- A new Opportunity and Support Guarantee for young people
- A safety net to “always be in place” for those who cannot work.
Secretary of State Pat McFadden has confirmed that Government will accept some of the core recommendations of the report, with Government departments being instructed to find the cash. Milburn himself has agreed to chair the Government's new Youth Opportunity Committee and will help oversee the implementation with specific deliverables set for before the next general election.
Enginuity will continue to work closely with Government to help ensure policy is delivered in a way that works for both young people and employers.
Sign up to our Policy Centre to feed your experiences into policy design and help shape how these ambitions work in practice. If there is a policy issue affecting your business, or a skills challenge you think government needs to understand, we want to hear from you. Contact us at [email protected].
Sign up to the Policy Centre email listMore news


